Comments on: Man on Wire: Enough Inspiration for Film, Memoir, Novel

By: shirleyhs

shirleyhs — Wed, 03 Feb 2010 23:51:22 +0000

Welcome, Jim! I'd love to hear more about Philippe Petit's memoir from you. We don't have to take Joe's word. We want to hear from those who disagree also. I'm even open to reading the memoir. However, I have only three hours/day available for both reading and blogging and have lots of other memoirs to read and write about. So, I end up choosing among good things and having to let some go. Tell me what you loved. I'm sure other readers want to know also.

By: Jim Moore

Jim Moore — Wed, 03 Feb 2010 22:21:13 +0000

Joe Smith is quite wrong. James Marsh took his film from Philippe Petit's memoir, which in James's own words is extremely cinematic. Why would you consider reading a novel and not the source? How sad.

By: shirleyhs

shirleyhs — Sun, 31 Jan 2010 23:29:25 +0000

Hi, Joe. Welcome to 100memoirs.com! I am glad to have your confirmation of my hunch that after watching the film, I don't have to read the book. I am, however, even more interested in Colum McCann's book now! One purpose reviews and recommendations serve is guiding us on how to use our precious time most wisely. I am grateful for both comments.

By: Joe Smith

Joe Smith — Sun, 31 Jan 2010 10:19:21 +0000

I have read the memoir and it is very NOT like the film. The film is very well made and crafted for any audience to enjoy. The book is elitist and egomanical. The director James Marsh did a good job of slightly covering up Petit larger than life ego. I suggest you skip the book and read Colum McCann's book. He is a much better writer.